As much as I find these different things to be very interesting, I can't help but think of the impact of these labels on the students. The student who has the label "MR" desperately wants to be a United States Marine like his two older brothers. He is highly determined and actually appears to be a very intelligent person. His social worker is currently in the process of having him retested because she does not believe that the diagnosis that has been placed on him is correct, nor do I. From what I have witnessed, the main difficulties that this student posses are simply reading and speech ones, leading me to believe with the limited observations I have had, that he might simply have a processing disorder (some kind of learning disability)and possibly a speech disorder. But, with the MR/ID diagnosis this kid would never be able to achieve his dream, or anything that he would actually really enjoy doing. However, with a reading or speech disability there is a much higher chance of him being accepted into a military program.
In class, we learned about these labels and even at that point I believed that in a perfect world students wouldn't need these labels to receive services. Everyone has weaknesses and everyone has strengths if the schools do not change to meet this fact and provide high quality instruction to all students, labeled or not, than these students who do not necessarily need a label, will continue to be stigmatized. That point that I just made is also made in the following video.
In this article (http://www.intellectualdisability.info/families/overview-of-learning-disability-in-children), they discuss what exactly the label intellectual disability means and my favorite quote that really relates to the student in my field placement was, "People with intellectual disabilities and their parents are at risk of being undervalued and stigmatized." I think that is exactly what is going on with students like the one I have mentioned before. The stigma associated with his diagnosis often gets his abilities and strengths to be undervalued.
I love the name of your blog! Great post.
ReplyDeleteThank you!
Delete